Severe turmoil is hitting European football following a complaint filed with the European Commission against UEFA and the European Football Clubs (EFC), focusing on club representation and the concentration of power in the hands of the elite. Specifically, the Union of European Clubs (UEC) is challenging the agreement under which UEFA recognizes the European Football Clubs (EFC) as the "sole body" representing football clubs across Europe. The UEC is asking the European Commission to investigate whether this exclusive agreement violates EU competition rules against anti-competitive practices and the abuse of a dominant market position. The UEC argues that exclusive representation, combined with what it describes as unequal voting rights within the EFC, allows top clubs to shape rules affecting the entire pyramid of European football. As it contends, this helps major clubs, such as Paris Saint-Germain and Bayern Munich, entrench their advantage in an industry generating tens of billions of euros in annual revenue. "The question is simple: Who gets a say in shaping the rules that determine the future of every club? Today, one association has been granted that mandate for all clubs in Europe, while most clubs have no meaningful voice within it," stated Dennis Gudasic, CEO of Croatian side Lokomotiva Zagreb and General Secretary of the UEC. The effort to persuade the European Commission to launch an investigation is expected to be difficult.
The reluctance of DG Competition
The Commission's powerful competition enforcement arm, the Directorate-General for Competition (DG Competition), has historically shown reluctance to initiate investigations into cases involving football, viewing them as politically sensitive matters, according to current and former senior officials of the department.UEFA also maintains close ties with the European Commission. Its president, Aleksander Čeferin, and the European Commissioner for Sport, Glenn Micallef, renewed a cooperation agreement during a meeting held last week in Nyon, Switzerland. Conversely, relations between Brussels and FIFA are typically cooler, according to three current and former European Commission officials. Nevertheless, Brussels has hesitated to open an official investigation against the world football governing body regarding the international match calendar, despite pressure from European lawmakers.Miguel Maduro, former Advocate General at the Court of Justice of the European Union and former chairman of FIFA's governance committee, provided advisory support to the UEC for its complaint.Maduro, who frequently criticizes the current governance system of European and world football, stated that the case "concerns the use of European competition law to protect the European sports model, which is built on genuinely open and balanced competitions." "A system in which a select group of top clubs acquires the power to decide who participates in European competitions and how revenues are distributed does not merely harm competition in European and domestic football. It gradually destroys the model of open and balanced competitions that UEFA itself claims to protect," he added.
Who represents the clubs?
The UEC bases its arguments in part on the landmark 2023 ruling regarding the European Super League, issued by the EU's highest court. It argues that the principles governing how UEFA authorizes rival competitions should also apply to its agreement with the EFC. "Whoever controls access to European football must do so on transparent, objective, and non-discriminatory terms. An agreement that forces clubs into exclusive representation by an association in which most have no say, and excludes from membership those who join another association, does not meet these conditions," Maduro stated.
EFC regulations prohibit its members from participating in other cross-border football club associations, unless those specific bodies have been recognized by the EFC alongside FIFA or UEFA. The UEC maintains that smaller clubs hold no meaningful influence inside the EFC, which currently counts 920 members across men's and women's football and is led by influential Qatari executive Nasser al-Khelaifi. For its part, the EFC states on its website that all member clubs have the right to vote in electing representatives to its executive board and the other bodies guiding its operations. The founding of the UEC in April 2023 had garnered the support of then-Vice President of the European Commission, Margaritis Schinas. The UEC reported that one club was warned in May 2024 that it would lose its EFC membership if it remained in the new organization. Furthermore, it claimed that 59 clubs requested that their participation in the UEC remain confidential out of fear of potential retaliation. The organization's complaint also challenges the EFC's influence over how UEFA competitions are structured and run.
According to the UEC, the EFC appoints 16 of the 20 members of UEFA's Club Competitions Committee, which reviews changes to tournament formats, qualification criteria, and prize money. The Union argues that this grants a limited group of clubs the authority to set rules affecting teams across the entirety of Europe. The UEC further contends that European competition prize money reinforces the advantage of clubs already sitting at the top. Research cited in its briefing note states that one English club received 110 million euros from UEFA in a single season, an amount roughly equivalent to half the total annual revenue of several of its Premier League rivals, based on 2023 figures. The same study, for which the UEC supported part of the data collection and processing, also found that roughly 50 clubs have occupied nearly 80% of Champions League spots since 2000. The UEC argues that the governance system and revenue distribution arrangements perpetuate this trend. The organization is asking the European Commission to obtain and make public the current Memorandum of Understanding between UEFA and the EFC, as well as to order the abolition of any restrictive clauses. In this way, the path could open for other club representation bodies to gain recognition and participate in the decision-making process, while the EFC would continue to represent its own members. "We fully respect the role of UEFA," stated UEC President Ovidiu Costeșin, general manager of Romanian champions Universitatea Craiova. "However, respect cannot mean silence."
www.bankingnews.gr
Σχόλια αναγνωστών