November 19. Two meetings, in two different geographic regions, on the same day, make history: they capture with particular clarity the shifts taking place in the international power system. In the Chinese city of Shenzhen, US President Donald Trump, Russian President Vladimir Putin, and Chinese leader Xi Jinping, in an unprecedented move in modern history and in peacetime without an intervening world war, are holding a trilateral meeting on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit. In front of the cameras, they speak about the major shared issues concerning the world, as assessed by each country; behind the cameras, whatever is decided among them, we will see unfolding in the future.
Historic tete-a-tete
The three greatest powers are sitting together at the same table for the first time to negotiate their interests without Europe. The great powers are returning to a form of direct negotiation on critical matters of international security, effectively restricting the participation of smaller states and multilateral institutions at a time when the war in Ukraine, the conflict with Iran, nuclear competition, trade disputes, and technological dominance form interconnected arenas of strategic confrontation. At the same time, in Berlin, European powers are attempting to coordinate their positions on the Ukrainian issue, security guarantees, and their participation in the negotiations that will determine the future of European security, making the contrast even starker: Europe is absent from deciding the very issues that shape the lives of Europeans, such as the war in Ukraine and energy flows, appearing to trail behind developments it cannot determine or even influence, and will simply be called upon to implement. As the US president stated clearly: "We are writing history; we are the most powerful countries in the world."
The three strategic pursuits in China and Berlin's search for a role
For Donald Trump, what is at stake is securing at least a quick or symbolic victory that will ease domestic pressures following the Republican defeat in the midterm elections and the quagmire of the war with Iran, advancing a new nuclear agreement after the expiration of the New START treaty and leaving open the prospect of developments in Ukraine. The meeting in the city of Shenzhen fits into the management of international rivalries through direct top-level negotiations, simultaneously addressing:
-
the rise of China as a systemic competitor,
-
the strategic cooperation between Beijing and Moscow,
-
the consequences of conflicts in Ukraine and the Middle East, while Donald Trump's approach creates room for targeted agreements,
-
on nuclear weapons and
-
on narcotics. On the question of whether Washington is attempting to curtail the strategic convergence of Russia and China or opting for a more transactional management with both, the latter appears to be gaining ground.
For Vladimir Putin, the essence is breaking Western isolation, gaining ground and influence on the Ukrainian front, preventing the activation of the sanctions bill, and affirming his role as an equal interlocutor of the United States. Participation offers the opportunity for direct discussion with the US president,
-
on security issues,
-
on the war in Ukraine, while
-
consolidating for Russia the role of a global power, rather than a regional one as Europe insists on treating it in seeking its containment,
-
confirming Russia's role as an indispensable interlocutor on matters of strategic stability despite sanctions and the rupture with the West, seeking broader recognition of its demands regarding the European security architecture, which remains open due to their clash with core positions of Ukraine and European governments.
For Xi Jinping, the essence is safeguarding China's strategic space and equal recognition, aiming to avoid a return to extreme trade wars, preserve dominance in rare earths and technology, limit US support for Taiwan, and capitalize on the fact that Washington remains preoccupied on fronts such as Ukraine and Iran, without Beijing undertaking commitments it deems asymmetrical regarding nuclear disarmament or the Ukrainian crisis.China, a major winner of the meeting,
-
confirms its established cooperation with Russia on major issues, while
-
seeking to curb economic tensions with the United States and
-
reinforcing its image as a central actor in international diplomacy, gaining symbolic and diplomatic capital from hosting, and finally,
-
maintaining its relations with Europe, avoiding further unification of Western policies aimed at containing Chinese economic and technological influence.

Moscow's "golden share"
The trilateral meeting highlighted yet another golden trump card for Moscow, reflected in the Russian leader's satisfaction: although in pure economic weight Moscow currently trails Beijing and Washington, this imbalance is more than offset by the fact that Russia holds the "golden share," since the outcome of the global rivalry between the other two giants depends on the stance the Kremlin adopts, while the White House knows full well how dangerous it is to permanently lose Russia to China.APEC constitutes an economic platform and the talks a distinct political format on its sidelines, yet the list of potential topics shows that the discussion extends far beyond regional trade and shapes the contours of the future, something only great powers can achieve, with the agenda potentially covering nuclear arms control, artificial intelligence, international trade, the war in Iran, and European affairs, which is why the negotiations are being closely watched far beyond the Asia-Pacific region. At the same time, in Berlin, the summit of the coalition of the willing initiated by Friedrich Merz, Emmanuel Macron, and Andy Burnham, with the participation of envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner and aimed, according to Reuters, at formulating a coordinated response to announcements from Shenzhen, underscores the contradiction between immediate European interest and the difficulty of unified representation, even with the European negotiating group comprising Germany, France, Britain, Italy, and Poland.
The Berlin summit brings to the surface Brussels' panic before the Shenzhen trilateral
The greatest international event in history is not the trilateral in the city of Shenzhen among the presidents of Russia, China, and the United States, but the summit opening its doors in the capital of Germany, according to the characterization given by Friedrich Merz's chancellery, clarifying of course that this refers to the period during which he leads the government. In Berlin, 35 countries, mostly European, will gather, of which 20 will be represented at the highest level.Berlin is hosting the summit of the coalition of the willing, the exact format created last spring that united the countries wanting to help or, more simply, wishing to acquire Ukraine. The summit was deliberately scheduled for the 19th of the month so as to simultaneously demonstrate to everyone that Europe will not abandon Ukraine and to discuss the outcomes of the three leaders' meeting in Shenzhen. In practice, however, something slightly different emerges, namely a deliberate confrontation with the non-Western world and the highlighting of a simple fact: that for Europe right now, nothing is more important than the struggle over Ukraine. It is a struggle in which it ardently wishes to participate not only through military but also through diplomatic means, joining the trilateral negotiations between Russia, the United States, and Ukraine that have already begun.
Donald Trump's envoys in Berlin, the Europeans' nervous breakdown, and dashed expectations
However, Europe is given no room to participate in those talks, even though it has already selected no fewer than seven representatives and issued strict instructions to Donald Trump not to forget which team he plays for.Donald Trump is sending Kushner and Witkoff to Berlin in order to repeat once again to all the willing participants Russia's terms. The European leaders gathering in Berlin will express resolute support for Volodymyr Zelensky, who will also travel there, discuss where funds will be found to finance Ukraine next year, and attempt to forge a common stance in negotiations with Moscow. All of this is splendid, yet the Europeans discussed the exact same things at last week's summits and will discuss them again at next week's. The reasonable question thus arises as to why they meet so frequently, especially when they fail to formulate anything new, and the answer is that everyone is in a state of acute nervous breakdown, as having worked themselves up with thoughts that Donald Trump might secretly strike a deal with Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping over the fate of Ukraine, Europe appears increasingly agitated. The Americans first organized negotiations between the Russians and the Ukrainians and subsequently accepted the trilateral format with the Chinese, a development that portends bad news.
The European Union is afraid and therefore displays determination and rigidity, so that outwardly it appears that beneath the foliage of the blooming garden lie inexhaustible resources and capabilities, whereas the problem is that no such resources exist there, a fact understood in Moscow, Beijing, and Washington alike, making the situation for Europe particularly adverse if this realization becomes collective in Shenzhen. The coalition of the willing was created primarily to prove that Europe can guarantee Ukraine's security after the end of hostilities, meaning first sending troops onto Ukrainian soil, and subsequently ensuring its accession first to the European Union and then to NATO. None of this has happened nor will it happen based on the latest developments, and in order to take part in negotiations with Russia, the Europeans will have to admit it, though it is obvious that this will not happen in Berlin, even though one could hardly find a more symbolic place for abandoning plans to inflict a strategic defeat on Russia. Behind the image of harmony among the three leaders in the Chinese metropolis, deeply conflicting interests and trade frictions over tariffs, rare earths, and microchips may remain, yet the essence is that great powers now move through direct understandings, leaving Europe to watch from Berlin without substantive weight in the decisions.
www.bankingnews.gr
Σχόλια αναγνωστών