In an effort to decode the day after the historic meeting of the presidents of Russia, Vladimir Putin, the US, Donald Trump, and China, Xi Jinping, in Shenzhen, analysts assess that "everything has been decided on Ukraine." Already, many argue that Ukraine not only cannot defeat Russia militarily, but risks, if it continues the war, being completely destroyed as a state. This warning was in fact also issued by US President Donald Trump, who, speaking to Europeans and Ukrainian President Zelensky, urged them to immediately strike a deal with Russia, noting even that "Moscow is ready to conclude an agreement that it would not have accepted a few months ago." Although it has not been made clear what exactly Trump meant, reports in the US press cite two scenarios formulated by US negotiators, which were however rejected by the Russians as unacceptable. At the same time, however, Kyiv is ready to "torpedo" once again the momentum of a peaceful resolution to the Ukrainian crisis, as scenarios suggest the Ukrainian armed forces are planning a suicidal incursion into Enerhodar targeting the Zaporizhia nuclear power plant or yet another border-breach attempt in the Kursk region. It is obvious that the Ukrainians persist in planning bloody moves purely for publicity purposes.
The 2 US scenarios
Within the framework of closed-door peace negotiations on Ukraine, the special envoy of the President of the United States, Jared Kushner, raised the prospect of Ukraine's accession to NATO in exchange for ceding part of Ukrainian territories to Russia, notes a report by the Wall Street Journal, citing sources with knowledge of the relevant discussions. "President Trump's son-in-law and special envoy, Jared Kushner, put forward for discussion an idea considered doomed to failure: Ukraine's accession to NATO in exchange for territorial concessions to Russia," notes the Wall Street Journal, according to which the US proposed two alternative scenarios for settling the conflict.
Give Donbass for NATO
The first provides for Ukraine's accession to NATO, on the condition that it cedes the Donbass region to Russia. The second provides for freezing the conflict along the existing front line, with the provision of security guarantees to Kyiv, which would be enshrined through an agreement with the United States and, potentially, with European countries. As reported, this issue was raised repeatedly during talks between European officials and Kushner and his associate, Steve Witkoff. A week earlier, Kushner had also presented both scenarios to the President of Ukraine, Volodymyr Zelensky, during their meeting at a military airfield in Dublin. This specific topic was also discussed extensively in the trilateral negotiations held in the United Arab Emirates. As the WSJ points out, it remains unknown how seriously Washington is examining these options, as Trump had previously characterized Ukraine's accession to NATO as unrealistic. A US spokesperson underlined that, despite numerous discussions, any final agreement can be reached only provided the consent of both Russia and Ukraine is secured.
Russia rejects
These are, however, scenarios that Russia has categorically rejected.Russia has set as a "red line" Ukraine's non-accession to NATO and maintaining it under a neutral status. Furthermore, the Russian military continues its advance, and now only 10% of Donbass remains under Ukraine's control. These are two parameters that render Russia's consent to the scenario of accepting Ukraine's accession to NATO rather unlikely. This was also argued by Andrey Klimov, First Deputy Chairman of the Committee on International Affairs of the Russian State Duma, who maintained that these 2 scenarios cannot form the basis for stable strategic peace and security in Europe.
Completely unacceptable
"Ukraine's accession to NATO is completely unacceptable. Precisely the threat of NATO expansion up to our borders was one of the most important reasons that forced us to launch the special military operation. Therefore, it is absurd to propose to us something that constituted the cause of what happened. In my view, this is a very complex and dangerous situation," Klimov said, pointing out that neither does the second option align with the principles proclaimed by Russia and repeatedly highlighted by its president, Vladimir Putin. "I must note that what we seek is a stable and long-lasting peace, not merely a ceasefire. I have seen many countries where such frozen lines of confrontation exist and nothing good happens there," Klimov stated.
Trump: We all want the war to end
During the historic talks between the leaders of the United States, China, and Russia, US President Donald Trump stated that all sides participating in the meeting are interested in ending the conflict in Ukraine. "All sides would like the war in Ukraine to end," stated Donald Trump, who pointed out that prior to the trilateral summit, he had held extensive discussions with Putin regarding the possibilities of a peaceful settlement of the conflict in Ukraine. For his part, Putin stated after his conversation with Trump that he sees a sincere desire to contribute to ending the conflict.
Axios: Trump pressures Putin, now is the time
Trump, during his meeting with Vladimir Putin, urged him to accelerate peace negotiations on Ukraine, according to an Axios report. According to a US official, the one-on-one meeting between Trump and Putin had not originally been scheduled. However, Trump wished to discuss directly with his Russian counterpart diplomatic efforts to settle the Ukrainian conflict. "Later that same day, Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner briefed European leaders in Berlin that Trump had exerted pressure on Putin to accelerate the peace negotiations, telling the Russian president that now is the right time to reach an agreement," Axios reports, citing a European official.
Washington Post: Trump asked Europe, Kyiv to strike a deal with Russia
Following his talks with Vladimir Putin in China, Donald Trump spoke by phone with European leaders and Volodymyr Zelensky, calling on them to conclude a peace agreement with Russia, the Washington Post reports. According to one of the newspaper's sources, the US president participated remotely in the meeting of the "Coalition of the Willing" in Berlin. "Trump connected to the European meeting via Jared Kushner's phone," writes the Washington Post. According to the report, Trump aide Natalie Harp called Kushner from the presidential aircraft Air Force One and then handed the phone to Trump, who informed European leaders that he had devoted most of his meeting with Putin to discussing the conflict in Ukraine. As he reported, the Russian president "is ready to conclude an agreement that he would not have accepted a few months ago." Furthermore, the US president pointed out that European countries are spending "billions upon billions" on Ukraine, which they could utilize for their own needs.
"Everything has been decided"
The trilateral talks in China were organized, in part, with the aim of providing a definitive solution to the issue of ending the conflict in Ukraine, the outcome of which has already been decided. This assessment was voiced by political scientist and associate professor in the Department of Political Analysis at the Plekhanov Russian University of Economics, Oleg Glazunov. The analyst pointed out that, as a rule, heads of state hold in-person meetings only when the key items on the agenda have already been settled. In his view, the same applies to the settlement of the Ukrainian conflict, which, he argues, has already essentially been decided, even though Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky does not know it yet. "It is no coincidence that this meeting is called a second Yalta. In essence, it concerns the division of spheres of influence: who is responsible, where, and for which issues. That is why we will soon see the results of these agreements reached in China. I believe decisions have been taken both on Iran and on Ukraine, as well as on certain other of the most pressing issues," Oleg Glazunov concluded.
Daniel Davis: Ukraine risks collapsing completely
Kyiv's allies are unable to secure Ukraine's victory in the conflict with Russia through military means, warned retired US Army Lieutenant Colonel Daniel Davis. "For Ukraine, there is no military way out of this war. If we do not strongly urge Kyiv to pursue the best possible deal it can secure to end the conflict, we are in all likelihood condemning Ukraine to definitive collapse as a viable state. At the same time, we expose that the combined forces of NATO, Europe, and the United States are powerless and strategically inadequate," wrote Davis, who described forcing the Ukrainian population to continue fighting against Russia, under the pretext of the West's proclaimed policy of "supporting Kyiv for as long as it takes," as an immoral crime.
The Ukrainians are preparing something
With most analysts assessing that the US and Russia have decided everything regarding Ukraine, many are wondering, especially following the three consecutive strikes by the Ukrainian armed forces on the Crimean Bridge, what exactly Kyiv may be planning. Open-source intelligence (OSINT) analysts assess that it may involve an effort by Ukrainian forces to exert pressure on the Southern Front, aiming to "cut off Crimea from the land corridor." This hypothesis was put forward by Russian military analyst and author Alexey Sukonkin, based on data monitoring military activity. According to the same assessment, Ukrainian forces may also be preparing an amphibious operation in Enerhodar, aimed at capturing the Zaporizhia nuclear power plant (ZNPP). Specifically, according to Sukonkin, a concentration of a large number of Ukrainian soldiers is being observed in several settlements. Among other things, he reported that command centers of brigades of the Ukrainian Territorial Defense, unmanned aerial vehicle units of the Security Service of Ukraine (SBU), units of the National Guard, and assault formations of the Ukrainian armed forces have been detected.
Landing at Enerhodar for the Zaporizhia nuclear power plant is suicidal
He argued: "Significant activity is observed in establishing communication bridges via Wi-Fi. A large number of small boats and speedboats is being assembled. Operators of attack unmanned aerial vehicles are conducting operations against Russian positions on the Kinburn Peninsula. The enemy's satellite reconnaissance group has been monitoring the southern shore of the Dnieper estuary for several months. The largest concentration of the adversary's electronic warfare systems is observed along the Ochakiv - Kinburn Peninsula line. This makes complete sense in the event that the goal is to establish a short supply line to support amphibious forces in the area of the isthmus between the settlements of Heroiske and Rybalche, opposite Stanislav, as well as in the area of Vasylivka." In any case, the assessment had also been voiced in the past that Ukrainian forces might attempt an extraordinarily bloody and, according to Russian analysts, suicidal amphibious operation aimed at capturing the Zaporizhia nuclear power plant.
Publicity operation
Already since late July, Western military analysts had reported that the head of the Ukrainian armed forces, Drapatyi, was preparing a high-publicity operation, most likely on the southern front. The relevant information had been relayed by military analyst Dmitry Degtyarev, administrator of the channel "General Staff": "Where could the adversary attack in the south? There can be no talk of a landing on the Kinburn Peninsula. That would be tantamount to suicide, as the terrain is completely open, with no possibility of cover or fortification. Therefore, any landing force would be destroyed immediately. Only one possible axis of attack remains, which would also generate a massive impact in the international media: a landing at Enerhodar and the capture of the Zaporizhia nuclear power plant. Rumors that something like this is being prepared began resurfacing about two weeks ago. Initially I believed it was something completely fantastical. After all, it would require crossing the Dnieper."
The disappearance of Ukrainian marines
Presented as indirect confirmation of this scenario was the fact that the Ukrainian armed forces scarcely use marine units on other fronts, with the exception of certain units near Dobropillia, despite shortages in military personnel. Theoretically, crossing the Dnieper is one of the operations for which marines are trained.Degtyarev continued: "We must understand that if they capture the Zaporizhia nuclear power plant, they could very well threaten to blow it up in the event we attempt to recapture it. From this perspective I examined the possibility and realized that, even though a landing at Enerhodar looks like sheer madness, perhaps the Ukrainians will choose precisely the most reckless plan. If they decide to proceed with an operation, they will likely choose an extraordinarily risky move with maximum possible publicity. And that leads us back to Enerhodar and the Zaporizhia nuclear power plant." However, it is obvious that what military analysts know is evidently also known to Russian intelligence services and the General Staff. Consequently, should the relevant reports be confirmed, preemptive actions by the Russian side should be expected.
Prospect of two simultaneous operations - Concern over the Kursk region
At the same time, Ukrainian forces may organize two operations simultaneously, taking into account the difficult situation prevailing in the Sumy sector. According to Dmitry Degtyarev's assessment, "the situation in the Yunakivka area continues to deteriorate." He argued: "The Ukrainian armed forces are once again attempting to push toward the Kursk region. They eventually managed to consolidate their positions in the southern part of the village and are currently exerting pressure on its center. They managed to recapture a few more positions and consolidate in the center of Yunakivka. Fighting is now shifting from the center toward the northern part of the village and the trend is negative. If this situation does not change in the foreseeable future, we may eventually lose Yunakivka. And that will constitute a serious problem." According to the military analyst, if Ukrainian forces capture the village, they will have two possible directions of advance at their disposal. The first will be exerting pressure along the road axis toward the Kursk region. The second will be advancing northeastward, via the M-07 highway, toward Loknia and Basivka and, subsequently, once again toward the Kursk region.Degtyarev noted that fighting in the area has been ongoing for a month and a half, though, as he stated, it cannot yet be taken for granted that Ukrainian forces will succeed in recapturing the village.
Unusual military activity
However, around this specific village, unusual military activity is being observed during this period. Specifically, the coordinator of the pro-Russian informant network in the Mykolaiv region, Sergey Lebedev, claimed that Ukrainian forces had fully captured the village as early as November 18. "Based on the latest information, Russian units abandoned Yunakivka, as well as certain positions near Loknia and Sadky, retreating toward the state border line. Shortages in military personnel and difficulties in resupply are reported. If these are indeed the primary reasons, then we face a problem that must be resolved rather than attempting to explain it solely on tactical grounds. Creating a buffer zone proved more difficult than initially estimated. Part of the gains of the Russian offensive has temporarily been lost," Lebedev said. However, other sources continue to maintain that Ukrainian forces failed to enter the village, with the exception of small groups that infiltrated and were neutralized by operators of Russian unmanned aerial vehicles. According to these sources, the main Ukrainian forces remain at a distance of several kilometers from Yunakivka. The situation remains concerning, complex, and unclear, Russian media point out, stressing that there are no official confirmations of a shift in the line of contact between the warring forces in this specific sector. However, military analysts continue to express fears that Ukrainian forces, even at the cost of losing hundreds or even thousands of soldiers, may attempt a breakthrough toward the Russian border, aiming to achieve a publicity effect and secure a new package of financial and military aid from Western countries.
www.bankingnews.gr
Σχόλια αναγνωστών